Yosemite Caught in Showdown

Clinton and Congress prepare to duel over public-land use.

By Michael Doyle
The Fresno Bee - September 19, 199
8


The annual funding bill that keeps Yosemite National Park open is now the focus of the most important environmental showdown of the 105th Congress.

The pending test of wills between President Clinton and the Republican-controlled Congress, in an unpredictable new climate, will shape the future of public-land policies as well as Clinton's future relations with lawmakers.

It's also a showdown with particular relevance for Yosemite-area communities, which bitterly remember the government shutdown of 1995-96 and resulting loss of tourist revenue.

"We may run into a potential government shutdown, and I don't think the American public wants that," Sen. Max Baucus, D-Mont., said Friday.

Baucus is leading a Senate effort to strip eight particularly controversial environmental measures from the Interior Department's $13.4 billion spending bill. The so-called legislative riders, all opposed by the White House, cover ground ranging from mining, grazing, and logging policy to the construction of a 30-mile road through Alaskan wilderness.

Though not specially tailored for California, some of the riders would none-the-less affect the state where 40% of the land is owned by the federal government.

For instance, one measure would postpone new environmental regulations governing the 30,000 public-land mines California. Another would block the Interior Department from obtaining more money from the oil companies that drill off California's coast. A third imposes a moratorium on new management plans governing the 24 million acres of Forest Service land in California.

"We're coming up to the point where we need to do it," said Janice Gauthier, spokeswoman for the Forest Service's California office. "The [management] plans should reflect the current information that's out there, and a lot has happened in the past 10 years or so."

The environmental riders - about two dozen in total - are attached to the must-pass bills funding the federal government for fiscal 1999. If the bills don't pass by Oct. 1, some government agencies could shut down.

The riders are largely embraced by the 70-some members of the House Western Caucus, a mostly Republican group whose vice chairman is Mariposa Republican George Radanovich.

"You decry riders when you don't like them," Radanovich aide Tom Pyle said, but "these are products of long-standing disagreements over how public lands are managed."

The first political question is this: Is a scandal-weakened president more, or less, likely to veto such crucial spending bills over legislative language he doesn't like? The answer to that may depend on another political question: If the government shuts down because the funding bills are vetoed, will Clinton or Congress get blamed this time around?

Democrats and Republicans are now seeking answers.

"The current circumstances make it more likely that he'll veto thebill," Baucus predicted Friday. "The president must look strong."

Added Rep. Frank Pallone, an environmentally active New Jersey Democrat, "If anything, we're going to see him more inclined to veto [bills], to show that he's strong."

Republicans have been saying for weeks that Clinton may sling vetoes about, to do just that: change the subject from the sex-and-deception scandal that's been dogging him.

"When all is said and done, the test will be down at 1600 Pennsylvania Avenue," said Rep. Sherwood Boehlert, R-N.Y., who's often allied with environmental groups. "The White House has to stand strong."

The White House succeeded, in 1995 and 1996, in making sure the Republican-controlled Congress shouldered the public blame for a three-week government shutdown. Republicans still wince at the memory-"at all costs, a government shutdown will be avoided," Boehlert said-as do the California communities that felt the brunt of it.

Yosemite-area businesses, for instance, lost an estimated $8.9 million in tourist-related revenue during the shutdown, according to a study by the National Parks and Conservation Association. Mariposa County lost $10,000 a day in tax revenues.

"We've discussed on several occasions in this office how to avoid a repeat of the Yosemite closure," Pyle said.

With these concerns ripe among Republicans, a government shutdown appears unlikely. Still, Clinton and Congress will have to dance the