House OKs Reform on Park Concessions

The Senate must decide whether to sign off on the bill.

By Michael Doyle
Fresno Bee - October 14, 1998


WASHINGTON - The decades-long fight to change park concessions, propelled by revelations about old business dealings at Yosemite National Park, effectively concluded on the House floor Tuesday.

The House easily passed a park reform measure that eventually will change how big national parks like Yosemite, Sequoia and Kings Canyon pick hotel and restaurant operators. The legislation also will help Yosemite's curious neighbors track the park's budget and operating plans, and give park enthusiasts a new way to pay for their annual visits.

"It's taken us years and lots of work to get us to this point," said Rep. James Hansen, R-Utah. "This was a very difficult piece of legislation to put together."

To be sure, Hansen, chairman of the House parks subcommittee, has a few more hours to go before the 105th Congress adjourns. The Senate must still formally sign off on the bill it has passed once before, and the measure could be taken political hostage for unrelated purposes.

The measure, approved by voice vote, avoids past controversies like any effort to winnow out existing national parks, but goes beyond concession management.

For instance, national parks will have to start making available to the public their annual budgets, performance plans and five-year strategic plans. That will give Yosemite's neighbors, for instance, the chance to see more easily how the park divvies up its $19 million annual budget.

"Most of that information already exists, but not in one place," Yosemite spokesman Kendell Thompson said. "I'm sure there are people who would find it convenient to have it packaged together."

Park visitors and memorabilia collectors also will get to buy a new kind of annual park "passport." For $50 a year, people will be able to buy a stamp providing unlimited access to national parks. Like the Fish and Wildlife Service's popular duck stamps, the park stamp design will be selected through an annual competition. As about 15% of Yosemite's 4 million yearly visitors already buy the similar Golden Eagle Passport, and about 5,600 such passports are sold at Sequoia and Kings Canyon every year, the new passports have popular potential.

"It certainly is a major advantage to the visitor, if they're going to visit several parks," said Kris Fister, spokeswoman for Sequoia and Kings Canyon national parks.

The core of the legislation repeals a 1965 law governing park concessions. Perennial efforts to repeal the law were boosted in the early 1990s, with the news that Yosemite's then-concessionaire was only paying the government three-quarters of 1% of its revenues that exceeded $89 million. It took until this year, however, for the House and Senate to agree on legislation, and Yosemite's contract long since has been modified so that the equivalent of about 22% of gross revenues go to the park.

Some California-based park professionals worried Tuesday that the bill actually will make their work harder and make it difficult to replicate improvements recently undertaken at Yosemite.

For instance, they worry about the clout of a new concessions advisory board and the implications of contracting out the park service's concessions management.

"It leaves us in a less powerful position," Stephen Crabtree, San Francisco-based concessions management chief for the park service's Pacific West region, "and the concessionaire gets more power."

For future contracts, like a new one for Grand Canyon, the bill changes how the park service calculates the value of the concessionaire's investments. Existing contracts, like the one calling for Delaware North Park Services to spend at least $11 million in building the Wuxsachi visitors facility at Sequoia, will stay the same.

The bill eliminates one impediment to concession competition, which is the preference given incumbent concessionaires. However, small guide and packhorse services like the four that serve Sequoia and Kings Canyon retain this preferential right to renew.

The new Sequoia concessions contract taking effect Nov. 1, for instance, will run from between 15 and 30 years, depending on the size of the investment made by Delaware North Park Services. The bill calls for 10-year contracts, or 20 years at a maximum.